This post was originally published on this site.
Diving competition photograph via Wikimedia Commons.
Angie Griffin is a 46-year-old Massachusetts swimmer who has competed at the top of her age division in U.S. Masters Swimming for over a decade. Last April, at the national championships in San Antonio, she finished second in the breaststroke. It wasn’t until after the meet that she learned she lost to a man.
Hugo Caldas, a 47-year-old male competing in the women’s 45-49 division, took home five national titles that day — swimming visibly seconds ahead of his female competitors. Caldas previously competed in the men’s division from 2002 to 2004 and now holds more than a dozen records in the women’s division including titles in rowing, CrossFit, and weightlifting.
Griffin filed a formal protest with U.S. Masters Swimming and published an op-ed in Swimming World Magazine making the case plainly: coming in second to a biological male at a national championship is injustice. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton agreed, launching an investigation and eventually a lawsuit, calling the policy reprehensible and a demonstration of deep contempt for women.
USMS responded with a modified eligibility policy that sounded promising until you read the fine print. National championship events were quietly reclassified as local recognition programs, exempting them from the new requirements entirely. World Aquatics banned Caldas for five years after he refused a chromosome test. USMS, meanwhile, concluded that Caldas had demonstrated she was female.
When Griffin posted an article about Caldas’ history to a USMS community forum to warn her fellow competitors, an unnamed swimmer filed a grievance against her for unsporting conduct! Now she faces a lifetime ban from the organization — not for cheating or even poor sportsmanship, but for stating facts.
These are not professional athletes with sponsorships and legal teams. These are working women who swim before and after their jobs because they love the sport. As Griffin put it — it doesn’t matter if it’s the Olympics or the playground. Competitive fairness is non-negotiable. Angie Griffin isn’t backing down from this fight, and neither should we. Fighting for common sense and fairness is essential for women’s sports. Speaking the truth is not about bigotry, it’s about biology.
Follow us at PhyllisSchlafly.com to stay on top of the fight to keep men out of women’s sports – sign up for our emails at PhyllisSchlafly.com. Join us next time for the Phyllis Schlafly Report.
